Dual-observation
Al line-contrast–GTI Pareto · r23

同一套策略、同一 Al line-to-continuum 定义,同时放到 flare-rich 的 0800730101 MOS2 和近稳态的 0800730201 MOS2 上。r8–r23 依次测试多尺度/局部基线、line-anchored × high-band hybrid、episode closure、持续 core/shoulder、有限时间核对齐、纯 FOV CUSUM、corner-scaled CUSUM、双 CUSUM confirmation、对称 line-window 宽度、低-FOV alpha 标定、local scaled-excess,以及 scaled-residual Bayesian Blocks 的 alpha 灵敏度;目标是:0101 向右上推进,同时把 0201 保留在至少 95% 的 GTI。

← CDFS MOS audit 首页 ← 0101 单观测 benchmark ← 0201 negative control

95% 是保留率 guardrail,不是“零损失 null gate”。 用户将 0800730201 的要求从 ≥99% 放宽为 gti_fraction ≥ 0.95;页面据此再在 0800730101 的 Al line-contrast–GTI 平面取 joint frontier。只有同时具有 0101 的 Al/continuum 对比增益、足够 GTI,并且不把 0201 剪到 95% 以下,才值得进入后续 matched 4.background 和 XSherpa 验证。
common strategy IDs
4706

两条 MOS2 观测完全相同的参数候选。

0201 guardrail pass
3398 / 4706

保留至少 95% 的 2.filter GTI。

0101 frontier
106 reps

所有共同候选的 point-estimate frontier。

joint frontier
88 reps

先过 0201 ≥95%,再在 0101 右上方向筛选。

主坐标定义: L_Al/C = Al-K sideband-excess / [rate(1.00–1.40 keV) + rate(1.85–2.00 keV)];纵轴是 100×[(L_Al/C)_strategy/(L_Al/C)_2.filter−1],误差棒是 nested-PHA Gehrels delta-method 误差。它是 detector-space 筛选指标,不是拟合线 flux、SP flux 或 calibrated photon flux。广带 Q = rate(1.4–1.8)/[rate(1.0–1.4)+rate(1.8–3.2)] 只作为表中的 concordance control。实心点表示 0201 保留 ≥95%,空心点表示越过这个 guardrail。
Dual observation Al line contrast versus GTI Pareto plot
左:0101 flare-rich 的 Al line-contrast–GTI 平面;绿色虚线是 0201 ≥95% 下的 joint frontier。右:0201 近稳态 control;竖线是 95% 观测时间门槛。颜色区分 temporal-rule family。r15 以后没有直接相减 FOV/corner:先以低 FOV cells 标定 count-space alpha,再对 R_FOV−alpha R_corner 的统计量做筛选。r22 的 Blocks 只作用于该正确缩放的 residual,并在每段原始 2.filter live run 内以 Gaussian-measurements Bayesian Blocks 分段;它不是原始 FOV rate 的 Blocks,也不是 Poisson 两成分 SP 拟合。
r21–r23 更新: r21 的 local scaled-excess 扫描表面出现三个新点,但在 0101 的 Al–GTI 坐标上均与已有策略的 GTI 完全重合,因此没有推高真实边界。r22 新增 192 个 residual-Blocks candidates,并以 consensus sym 4.5、75-s、p0=0.05q=0.25z=2、15-s padding 得到 0101 99.08%、Al +0.72±1.15%,0201 100.00%、Al 0.00±1.39%。r23 仅把同一 Blocks 规则的 low-FOV alpha calibration 扩到 0.35/0.50:320 个通过 control 的新增点中,35 个数值不同坐标均被已有前沿支配,其余为已有 GTI 的等价重现。因此 alpha 灵敏度没有继续推高边界。r22 的小步只是在 point estimate 上连接/细化已有前沿,幅度小于一倍统计误差,仍不是 SP 检出。

目前最有用的 joint candidates

下表不是最终推荐清单,而是用来决定下一轮 matched 抽谱的代表点。Al-rate retention 是主坐标的保护性互检:它应与 0 相容;0201 的 Al 和广带 Q 也应与 0 相容。hybrid 的共识版本保留任一 selector 接受的时间;保守版本只保留两个都接受的时间。

strategy0101 GTI0101 Al / Al rate0101 broad Q diagnostic0201 GTI0201 Al0201 broad Qscreen
scaled-residual BB consensus: sym 4.5s x alpha=0.2, cell=75 s, p0=0.05, q=0.25, z=2, pad=15 s
scaled-residual BB: sym 4.5, alpha low 0.2, 75s, p0=0.05, q=0.25, z>2, pad 15s, retain union
99.08%+0.72% ± 1.15%
Al rate +0.32% ± 0.66%
+0.24% ± 0.83%100.00%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%joint frontier
scaled-residual BB consensus: sym 4.25s x alpha=0.2, cell=75 s, p0=0.1, q=0.25, z=1.5, pad=15 s
scaled-residual BB: sym 4.25, alpha low 0.2, 75s, p0=0.1, q=0.25, z>1.5, pad 15s, retain union
98.51%+1.03% ± 1.21%
Al rate +0.41% ± 0.71%
+0.47% ± 0.86%100.00%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%control-safe
alpha-tail paired CUSUM consensus: sym 4.5s x alpha=0.2, cell=75, q=0.15, k=0.1, H=2.5
alpha-tail paired CUSUM: sym 4.5, alpha low 0.2, 75s, retain union
98.97%+0.79% ± 1.16%
Al rate +0.39% ± 0.67%
+0.39% ± 0.83%99.99%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%joint frontier
upper symmetric-line paired CUSUM consensus: sym 4.5s x 90, q=0.35, k=0.25, H=4 (both)
symmetric upper-line grid 4.5 sigma × paired CUSUM confirmed_both retain union
99.37%+0.54% ± 1.10%
Al rate +0.32% ± 0.61%
+0.39% ± 0.81%99.99%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%joint frontier
FOV+corner CUSUM consensus: sym3p5s × 90_q0.35_k0.5_h4 (both)
paired FOV/corner CUSUM confirmed_both retain union: symmetric_3p5sigma × paired_cusum90_q0p35_k0p5_h4
98.03%+1.93% ± 1.28%
Al rate +0.59% ± 0.74%
+1.26% ± 0.90%99.99%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%joint frontier
corner-CUSUM consensus: sym4s × 90 q=0.35 k=0.25 H=4
corner-scaled high-band CUSUM retain union: symmetric_4sigma × corner_cusum90_q0p35_k0p25_h4
98.56%+1.22% ± 1.21%
Al rate +0.44% ± 0.70%
+0.67% ± 0.86%99.99%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%joint frontier
FOV+corner CUSUM consensus: sym3p5s × 90_q0.35_k0.5_h4 (both)
paired FOV/corner CUSUM confirmed_both retain union: symmetric_3p5sigma × paired_cusum90_q0p35_k0p5_h4
98.03%+1.93% ± 1.28%
Al rate +0.59% ± 0.74%
+1.26% ± 0.90%99.99%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%joint frontier
FOV+corner CUSUM consensus: sym3s × 90_q0.35_k0.5_h4 (both)
paired FOV/corner CUSUM confirmed_both retain union: symmetric_3sigma × paired_cusum90_q0p35_k0p5_h4
96.47%+2.73% ± 1.43%
Al rate +0.60% ± 0.84%
+1.87% ± 0.98%99.95%+0.06% ± 1.40%+0.00% ± 1.06%control-safe
corner-CUSUM consensus: sym2p5s × 45 q=0.25 k=0.25 H=3
corner-scaled high-band CUSUM retain union: symmetric_2p5sigma × corner_cusum45_q0p25_k0p25_h3
88.81%+5.45% ± 2.01%
Al rate +0.81% ± 1.24%
+3.89% ± 1.32%99.17%+0.14% ± 1.47%+0.05% ± 1.09%control-safe
CUSUM consensus: sym2p5s × 90 q=0.25 k=0.25 H=3
high-band Poisson CUSUM retain union: symmetric_2p5sigma × cusum_fov90_q0p25_k0p25_h3
89.06%+5.42% ± 1.99%
Al rate +0.97% ± 1.22%
+3.83% ± 1.31%99.17%+0.14% ± 1.47%+0.05% ± 1.09%control-safe
CUSUM consensus: sym2p5s × 60 q=0.25 k=0.25 H=3
high-band Poisson CUSUM retain union: symmetric_2p5sigma × cusum_fov60_q0p25_k0p25_h3
87.96%+6.53% ± 2.11%
Al rate +1.06% ± 1.28%
+4.01% ± 1.36%99.13%+0.18% ± 1.47%+0.05% ± 1.10%control-safe
aligned consensus: sym3s × BB90/.01/z1.5/close330 · dt +15 s
timing-aligned retain union: symmetric_3sigma × bb_fov90_p00p01_z1p5_pad0s, bridge <= 330 s, BB-BTI shift +15 s
95.01%+3.57% ± 1.55%
Al rate +0.90% ± 0.93%
+2.59% ± 1.05%100.00%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%control-safe
aligned conservative: sym2p5s × BB60/.01/z1.5/close120 · dt -30 s
timing-aligned retain intersection: symmetric_2p5sigma × bb_fov60_p00p01_z1p5_pad0s, bridge <= 120 s, BB-BTI shift -30 s
85.49%+7.53% ± 2.27%
Al rate +1.19% ± 1.38%
+4.67% ± 1.46%99.13%+0.18% ± 1.47%+0.05% ± 1.10%joint frontier
conservative: sym2p5s × bb60/.01/z1p5p15s
hybrid retain intersection: symmetric_2p5sigma × bb_fov60_p00p01_z1p5_pad15s
85.26%+7.67% ± 2.30%
Al rate +1.17% ± 1.39%
+4.82% ± 1.47%99.13%+0.18% ± 1.47%+0.05% ± 1.10%control-safe
sym 2p5σ
symmetric |z| <= 2.5
87.96%+6.53% ± 2.11%
Al rate +1.06% ± 1.28%
+4.01% ± 1.36%99.13%+0.18% ± 1.47%+0.05% ± 1.10%control-safe
BB30/.01/z1p5/p15s
BB high-band FOV 30-s: p0=0.01, excess>1.5 sigma, +/-15 s
64.13%+11.93% ± 3.71%
Al rate +1.25% ± 2.23%
+7.13% ± 2.30%100.00%+0.00% ± 1.39%+0.00% ± 1.06%joint frontier
standard_2filter
original 2.filter
100.00%+0.00% ± 0.00%
Al rate +0.00% ± 0.00%
+0.00% ± 0.00%100.00%+0.00% ± 0.00%+0.00% ± 0.00%control-safe
怎样判断“前沿突破”: 新策略必须在 0101 的右上方向超过现有 Al-primary joint frontier,同时在 0201 不把一个稳态观测人为剪短,也不产生显著正 Al contrast 或 Q。当前页面仍是 detector-space 筛选;下一步应对 joint frontier 的高保留率、中等 trade-off、强 contrast 三段各挑代表点,抽取匹配的 4.background,并用相同 XARTATOMS grouping、XSherpa 模型、residual 和 sky-background stability gates 验证。